|
Denitsa Laffchieva,
clarinet; Ofer Canetti, cello; Maria Prinz, piano
Weill Recital Hall at
Carnegie Hall
February 11, 2010
Three
musicians from different corners of the world, Maria Prinz from
Bulgaria; Denitsa Laffchieva from Bulgaria—but residing in
London; and Ofer Canetti from Israel, converged recently to
perform a program of Debussy, Strauss and Zemlinsky. The concert
was presented by MidAmerica Productions. Each musician impressed
in different ways, not always complementary to one another, but
ultimately providing a stimulating evening to their large
audience.
Opening with
Debussy’s Première Rhapsodie for clarinet and piano, Prinz
provided a gently colored backdrop for Laffchieva’s silky,
elegant clarinet sound. Both players managed the challenges of
the work with grace and ease overall, though this listener
somewhat missed the sensuous abandon heard in favorite
performances. Perhaps simply living with the work a bit more
would help. It’s also possible that placing the piano lid on the
half-stick (it was on full) might have rendered pianistic
details less constraining to the clarinetist.
Ofer Canetti
joined forces with the versatile Ms. Prinz in Strauss’s Sonata,
Op. 6. This was a full-bodied and impassioned performance.
Canetti is a powerfully communicative young musician of strong
temperament and technique. Some slipping of the endpin at the
beginning seemed ready to derail things, but he drove it into
the floor with force (from a height and with a loud thud) and
continued. One was at first surprised by this harpooning
exhibition, but with a player as naturally expressive and
unselfconscious as Mr. Canetti, such matters may unfortunately
escape consideration. Unfazed, he dove deeply into the work,
projecting each nuance with sensitivity, while keeping a firm
grip on the larger structure. Prinz ably held her own with her
demanding part (made more so by some unruly page-turns). A piano
on half-stick and more regular collaboration will bring them to
an even higher level.
The second
half consisted of the Zemlinsky Trio, Op. 3, a challenging,
Brahmsian work that requires a special advocacy to pull it off.
It seemed under-rehearsed here; despite some beautiful solos
passed between clarinet and cello, there was some groping in the
dark for the music’s shape and direction. The third movement of
the Brahms Op. 114 Trio was played as an encore, and the
performance made one wish that that trio had been played instead
of the Zemlinsky.
-Rorianne Schrade;
New York
Concert Review; New York, NY
|